Town Court


Beginning June 5, Small Claims filings can be accepted.  Suspension lift payments and fines due payments are currently being accepted.  

No one will be suspended for failing to appear or pay.  All payment due dates have been extended.  

Town Court is held Wednesdays in the Courtroom
Second floor of Town Hall

4:00 PM Small Claims/Eviction hearings - Hon. Mark J. Frentzel
4:00 PM Small Claims/Eviction hearings - Hon. Mark S. Nemeth
5:00 PM Criminal Matters
6:30 PM Traffic Matters

Court hours are Monday through Friday 8:30am – 4:30pm.

Fine payments are taken daily 8:30am – 4:00pm. Payment options include cash, money orders, Visa/Mastercard. NO PERSONAL CHECKS ACCEPTED.

Town Justices Mark S. Nemeth and Mark J. Frentzel share the bench on Wednesday evenings. Justice Nemeth sits every first and third Wednesday of the month. Justice Frentzel sits every second and fourth Wednesday of the month.

Grand Island court has jurisdiction over anyone 16 years and older. The court hears misdemeanor, violations and traffic matters only. We have no jurisdiction over felony charges, but can arraign a case with felony charges and hold felony hearing.

Assistant District Attorneys are assigned to our court, appearing every Wednesday evening, representing the people of the State of New York.

SMALL CLAIMS applications can be filed Monday through Friday from 9:00am – 4:00pm. A mandatory filing fee must be paid at the time of filing. The maximum claim allowed in a town court is $3,000. The fee for a claim of $1,000 or less is $10.00 and for a claim of $1,001 - $3,000 is $15.00. A Corporation cannot file a Small Claim matter in Town Court; they must go to the nearest City Court. A Small Claim Booklet and application are available free of charge at the court.

EVICTIONS filings can be made Monday through Friday from 9:00am – 4:00pm. The filing fee is $20.00. The defendant must be served no less than 10 days, but no more than 17 days prior to the court date. At the time of filing all original documents must be filed, including an Affidavit of Service. Paperwork must be filed the Friday prior to the Wednesday court date. YOU MUST CONTACT THE COURT TO CONFIRM A COURT DATE.

Please note major changes in Summary Proceedings has gone into effect as of June 14, 2019. Please refer to NYS RPAPL (Real Property Actions and Proceedin Law) for further information.

Please note that the Grand Island Court DOES NOT provide eviction paperwork.


Town Hall 716-773-9600 x650

Diane DeSimone, Chief Court Clerk

Maureen Lewis, Court Clerk

Jennifer Cammarano, Clerk to Town Justice

Kelly Behrens, Clerk to Town Justice

Grand Island Town Hall
Town Court (2nd Floor)
2255 Baseline Road
Grand Island, New York 14072
Fax: 716-775-3527